Is SOC 2 Mandatory? What Startups Need

By Bug Circuit Security Team
Is SOC 2 Mandatory? What Startups Need

Is your own website affected? Check it free in 2 minutes.

Passive outside check only. Nothing is attacked, no signup.

No, SOC 2 is not mandatory by law, but many business customers will not buy from you without it, so it can become mandatory in practice.

This post is for founders whose customer just asked, "Do you have a SOC 2?" You will learn what SOC 2 is, how it differs from SOC 3, what auditors actually look for, and a simple way to decide when to start. No jargon left unexplained.

What is SOC 2?

SOC stands for System and Organization Controls. SOC 2 is a report written by an independent CPA firm (a licensed auditor). It says whether your company protects customer data using controls that match a published framework.

The framework comes from the AICPA, the US accounting body. It is called the Trust Services Criteria. You can read the official overview on the AICPA SOC 2 page.

Two details matter for founders:

  • SOC 2 is an attestation report, not a government certificate. There is no pass or fail score like an exam. The auditor gives an opinion (it can be clean, qualified or adverse), and you share the report with customers.
  • You pick the scope. The report covers the systems and criteria you choose, not everything your company does.

What is SOC 2 and SOC 3? How they differ

SOC 3 is the short, public cousin of SOC 2. It uses the same criteria but leaves out the detail.

SOC 2 Type 1SOC 2 Type 2SOC 3
What it checksControls are designed well on one dateControls actually worked over a period of timeSame opinion as SOC 2 Type 2, summarized
Detail levelFull reportFull report with test resultsShort summary, no test details
Who can read itUnder NDA, to customersUnder NDA, to customersAnyone, can be posted on your website
Typical useFirst proof for early dealsWhat most enterprise buyers wantMarketing and trust page

In plain terms: Type 1 is a photo. Type 2 is a video. SOC 3 is the poster you hang on the wall.

Most buyers who send you a security questionnaire want the SOC 2 Type 2 report. Many will accept a Type 1 plus a clear plan while you build up your Type 2 history.

Is SOC 2 mandatory for startups?

No law says you must have one. Nobody fines you for skipping it. Regulations like HIPAA (US health data) or GDPR (EU privacy law) have their own rules, and SOC 2 is not a substitute for them.

So why does everyone talk about it? Because buyers use it as a shortcut. A company that buys software from you is trusting you with its data. Reading a SOC 2 report is faster and cheaper for them than auditing every vendor themselves.

Here is how it usually plays out:

  1. A mid-size or large customer sends a security questionnaire.
  2. One of the first questions is "Do you have a SOC 2 report?"
  3. If the answer is no, the deal slows down or stalls in their security or procurement review.

So it is a sales requirement, not a legal one. Some customers will accept a completed questionnaire, a recent security test and a good explanation instead. Ask what they actually need before you spend money.

SOC 2 requirements: the five Trust Services Criteria

The auditor tests you against up to five categories. Only the first one is required.

  • Security (required). Protect systems from unauthorized access. This is the core of every SOC 2.
  • Availability (optional). Your service stays up as promised.
  • Processing integrity (optional). Your system does what it says, accurately and on time.
  • Confidentiality (optional). Sensitive business data is limited to the right people.
  • Privacy (optional). Personal information is handled as you promise in your privacy notice.

Most startups begin with Security only, then add others if a customer asks. Fewer categories means a smaller audit.

What auditors actually look for

The criteria do not list exact tools. You decide how to meet them, then prove it with evidence. These are the controls most small teams end up with:

  • Written policies. Short documents covering access, acceptable use, incident response, and change management.
  • Access control. Unique accounts, multi-factor authentication (MFA, a second login step) on email, cloud and code tools, and removing access the day someone leaves.
  • Risk assessment. A simple yearly review of what could go wrong and what you do about it.
  • Change management. Code reviews or approvals before changes reach production.
  • Logging and monitoring. You collect logs and someone looks at alerts.
  • Vulnerability management. You find and fix security weaknesses on a regular schedule.
  • Incident response. A written plan, plus proof you know who does what.
  • Vendor management. A list of suppliers that touch customer data, and a check on how they protect it.
  • Encryption and backups. Data encrypted in transit and at rest, and backups you have tested.
  • People controls. Security training for staff and onboarding and offboarding checklists.

For Type 2, you also need evidence collected over time: tickets, screenshots, access reviews, training records. Auditors test samples from the whole period, not just the last week.

A quick self-check you can run today

Before you talk to an auditor, see how your public-facing basics look. These two commands work on macOS and Linux. Replace example.com with your domain.

curl -I https://example.com
dig TXT _dmarc.example.com +short

The first shows your HTTP response headers. Look for lines such as strict-transport-security and content-security-policy. You can also use the free security headers tool for a readable grade. The second checks whether you publish a DMARC record, which helps stop people from spoofing your email. A valid one looks like this:

v=DMARC1; p=quarantine; rua=mailto:dmarc-reports@example.com

Neither of these gets you a SOC 2. They are examples of the kind of basics a buyer's security team will quietly check before they even read your report.

When should a startup start SOC 2?

Use this simple decision path.

  1. No customers are asking yet. Do not start the audit. Do build the habits: MFA everywhere, written basic policies, tested backups, a code review rule.
  2. One customer asked, and the deal is small. Offer a completed questionnaire and a recent independent security test. Many buyers accept that.
  3. Two or more customers asked, or one large deal depends on it. Start now. Choose Security only and plan for Type 1 first, then Type 2.
  4. You sell mainly to enterprises or regulated industries. Treat SOC 2 as part of go-to-market and budget for it early.

The actual steps look like this:

  1. Pick your scope (which product, which criteria).
  2. Run a gap assessment against the controls above.
  3. Fix the gaps and write your policies.
  4. Pick a CPA firm. Compliance automation tools can help collect evidence, but the audit itself must come from a licensed CPA firm.
  5. Get the Type 1 report, then run a Type 2 observation period.

Costs vary a lot by auditor and company size, so get quotes rather than trusting a number from a blog.

Where a security test fits in

SOC 2 does not strictly require a penetration test (a safe, authorized attempt to break into your site to find weaknesses). Still, auditors and customers often ask whether you test for vulnerabilities, and a recent test report is useful evidence. The OWASP Top Ten is the common reference list of web risks that testers check.

Be clear about what this is. A small-site audit is not a SOC 2 audit and does not give you a SOC 2 report or any compliance certificate. It does find real bugs, which you can fix before a buyer's security team finds them. If you are unsure what to buy, see our guides on how much a penetration test costs and manual versus automated testing.

Key takeaways

  • SOC 2 is not a legal requirement. It becomes one in practice when buyers ask for it.
  • SOC 2 is a detailed private report from an independent CPA firm. SOC 3 is a short public summary of the same kind of opinion.
  • Start with the Security category only, and aim for Type 1 first, then Type 2.
  • Build the basics now: MFA, written policies, offboarding, backups, change review and regular vulnerability testing.
  • Ask your customer what they actually need before you commit to a full audit.

Next step

If a buyer wants proof you take security seriously, a good first move is knowing where your website stands. Start with our free website security check. If you want a person to look deeper, the $49 Circuit audit is a manual review of your site with a written report of every issue, severity, evidence and exact fixes. See pricing for details. It does not replace a SOC 2 audit, but it gives you real findings to fix and show.

Want certainty, not guesswork?

A real human security engineer audits your whole site by hand and sends a full report: every issue, its severity, and the exact fix. From $49, with a 14-day money-back guarantee.

See pricing

Frequently asked questions

Is SOC 2 mandatory?
No. No law requires a company to have a SOC 2 report. It becomes mandatory in practice when customers make it a condition of buying, which is common with mid-size and large business buyers.
What is SOC 2 and SOC 3?
SOC 2 is a detailed report from an independent CPA firm on how you protect customer data. SOC 3 covers the same kind of opinion in a short summary with no test details, so you can share it publicly on your website.
What are the SOC 2 requirements for a startup?
You must meet the Security criteria, which usually means written policies, MFA, access reviews, change management, logging, vulnerability management and an incident response plan. Availability, confidentiality, processing integrity and privacy are optional add-ons.
What is the difference between SOC 2 Type 1 and Type 2?
Type 1 checks that your controls are well designed on a single date. Type 2 checks that they actually worked over a period of time. Most enterprise buyers prefer Type 2.
When should a startup get SOC 2 compliance?
Start when more than one customer asks, or when a large deal depends on it. Before that, build the basics like MFA, written policies and tested backups, and offer a security questionnaire or recent security test instead.

Keep reading

See what attackers see, for free

Run the free passive check on your website. No login, no impact on your site, results in seconds.

Ready for the full manual audit? See pricing

Published by Bug Circuit. Written with AI assistance and reviewed for accuracy before publishing.