Choosing your first test

Bug bounty vs penetration test.

A bug bounty pays strangers per bug found; a penetration test pays one tester for a planned test and a report. For a small startup, the pentest usually comes first.

By the Bug Circuit security team · Last updated

Bug bounty vs penetration test for a small startup: which is better? For most small startups a penetration test comes first: one tester checks the whole app in a planned window and gives you a written report you can show customers and auditors, for a fixed price (Bug Circuit: $49 one-time for one app). A bug bounty pays per valid bug, has no report or fixed scope, and works best once the obvious issues are fixed and you have time to handle reports.

The offer at a glance

Bug bounty vs penetration test: price, scope and timing
What you get
Price$49 one-time for one website (Essential, 3 audits within one month). Pro is $99 a month for 2 websites, Premium $199 a month for 5.
Who testsA security engineer, by hand. Automated tools only help with discovery.
What you getA written report: every finding with its severity, evidence and the exact fix steps, plus a remediation roadmap.
TimingAbout 5 business days after testing starts. The 24-hour report is $15 more, and the $15 is refunded if the report is late.
RetestEach audit after the first on a website retests the previous findings in the same report.
Not includedFixes (quoted separately from the report), compliance certificates, and anything beyond one website on one domain without an Enterprise quote.
Before testingYou verify you own the website and sign the Authorization to Test. Nothing is tested without it.

Side by side

Side by side
Penetration testBug bounty
How you payA fixed price for a planned testPer valid bug, plus platform fees on most programmes
What you getA written report covering the whole scopeIndividual bug reports, as researchers find them
CoveragePlanned: every area in scope is testedUneven: researchers pick what pays
Evidence for customers and auditorsYes, the report and a letter of testingRarely accepted on its own
Work for your teamOne handover, one reportOngoing triage of incoming reports
Best timeBefore launch and once a yearAfter a pentest, when you can fix fast

A sensible order

  • First: a manual penetration test and fix the findings.
  • Then: a retest to confirm the fixes.
  • Later: a vulnerability disclosure policy, and a bug bounty when you can triage reports quickly.

Frequently asked questions

Is a bug bounty cheaper?
It can look cheaper because you pay only for bugs found, but platform fees, triage time and payouts add up, and you get no report for customers.
Do customers accept a bug bounty instead of a pentest?
Rarely. Security questionnaires and auditors usually ask for a recent penetration test report.
What does a pentest cost?
At Bug Circuit, $49 one-time for one app. Market prices are in our cost guide.
Should we have a security.txt first?
Yes, it tells researchers where to report. Our free security.txt generator makes one.
Can we do both?
Yes. Many companies run a yearly pentest and a bounty or disclosure programme alongside it.

Keep reading

Start with the free check

See your public attack surface in seconds, then order an audit when you are ready.

Ready for the full manual audit? See pricing